Decisions, Decisions

We are planning to have the house's exterior painted in the another week and I'm under the gun to choose colors and get things on and poppin'.

I used Sherwin William's color visualizer to help me decide on a great shade of gray.

First, up is Classic French Gray for walls, Wool Skein for trim and Tricorn Black for shutters. Nice, crisp and classic.

I don't know how I wound up with this color combo but I really like it too. There's Light French Gray for the walls, Greek Villa for trim and Homburg Gray for shutters. Pretty, right?

Which one do you like? Does the bottom one give a country cottage feel? Because I'm not going for that.. Would a black glossy front door give it some edge? Or should I stick to the tried and true classic of the first option?